Not your typical Pizza joint, the menu is very open in terms of they do not just focus on Italian food. They have an excellent lunch menu, if you are able to get your hands on it.
Shrimp Scampi Pie is AMAZING.... everything from here is always great. And delivery is quick also.
This is a Staten Island tradition, we have been ordering from On the Plaza for over 15 years on and off and every time we have it, it always tastes delicious. Agree that it may be a bit oily but it's worth every bite.
All of their slices are very very delicious, the sausage & pepperoni mix is also very tasty. The only problem is it is very very oily/greasy. I guess sometimes you just have to let loose and deserve this treat but be aware it's not for the weak stomachs.
Garlic Knot Sandwiches are really tasty